Manuscript Evaluation Form For Peer Reviewers

Manuscript Title:

Reviewer Name:

Dear Reviewer:

Please review the enclosed manuscript that has been submitted to the journal of Chandigarh University. This is a blind review; neither your identity nor that of the authors will be revealed. Please be sure to provide additional comments to the Editors. Kindly return this review report to cuglobalmgtreview@cumail.in as an attached file.

Rankings: 1 = unacceptable; 5 = excellent

Evaluation Criteria (1-5) :

Popularity of the subject (1-5):

Suitability for the journal (1-5):

Quality of research design (1-5):

Adequacy of data analysis (1-5):

Contributions to the literature (1-5):

Legitimacy of conclusions (1-5):

Practical/managerial significance (1-5):

Clarity of presentation (1-5):

Your Editorial Decision:

( ) Accept
( ) Accept after Specified Revision
( ) Reject

Remarks to the Editor:

(This section of the form is for journal editors only. Your suggestions are valuable)